Thursday, February 25, 2010

From Mandriva to Mint

I have liked Mandriva since Mandrake Linux 9.1. Its been an amazing distribution ever since. Pure visual delight and ease of use. I like KDE for the look and feel, GNOME is mostly a no no for me. Mandriva being a KDE centric distro fits the bill perfectly. Mandriva is the default king of our two year old Family Desktop. We all loved the latest version and despite KDE being a little buggy, find it convenient to use.
I gave this info to emphasize that it was not easy for me to think about moving from Mandriva to any other distro, specially a GNOME centric Mint. Here goes the story :

My wife's vaio completed 1 year and ran out of official warranty. Hence she allowed me to dual boot it with Mandriva and Vista. She was already comfortable with Mandriva, so it was supposed to be a smooth move. The problem started right after the first install.

  1. The boot was fast but DKE would come up with plenty fo Akonadi errors. We tried searching for solution, but nothing on net/forums. As this was not causing any usage error so this was low priority.
  2. Keyboard would hang. Yeah, while working all of a sudden keyboard would stop responding. We had to kill X-Server and restart for keyboard to be functional again. This was a big issue and evry frustrating.
  3. The webcam worked with r5u870 drivers, but the inbuilt mic would not agree to work. Now I am using Linux since 5 years and am fairly conversant with Mandriva. Still I could not make it work.
  4. Hibernation sucks. This is the first time I tried Mandriva on Laptop and I must say hibernation is great even in Vista. When I simply close the lid, the system does not go into hybernation. Though this was resolved quickly with some tips from Ubuntu forums, but it should work by default. More troubling is that comming up from hybernation is nto guranteed. Yuck !!! Strange but true. Many times even after clicking hibernate ( and not merely closing lid) the system would not resume. I would see some activity in battery and hard disk lights and some flicker on screen, but thats all. Even command line would not come up. CTRL+ ALT+ BKSP also does not work. My wife was so used to of closing the lid in Vista that she said its better to use Vista itself.
  5. Plasma would crash and cause the X-Server to restart. Now I have seen plasma crashes in Desktop, but restarting X-Server means loosing all the unsaved work. This was unacceptable.

I wanted to stick to Linux, but Mandriva was causing lots of issues. We started looking for more options. My first choice was Arch Linux, which I use on my main desktop, however, my wife wanted something easy to administer with all GUI controls. We went to distrowathc and started looking at distributions as per Page hit ranks. She kind of liked Ubuntu looks, but was floored by Mint screenshots. She said this amazing and she would be happy to use it. Actually despite being a GNOME Desktop Mint 8 looks evry good. Also, due to known Plasma crashes, we were ok to try GNOME.

Now Mint is a pure delight once it boots, the LIVE CD takes a huge time to boot. The looks were as impressive as in the screenshots and operation evry smooth. The webcam mic worked in the LVIE CD itself and even after 24 hours of use there was no crash/ hang. Satisfied with LIVE D test, we went ahead with the install. Here are my thoughts :

  1. All regular hardware works out of box. Things like Wireless, Bluetooth and USB Scanner/Printer require no config at all. Webcam worked fine with r5u870 drivers and Mic was functional with little tweaking.
  2. Despite being GNOME, it looks and feels like KDE and hardly any difference while working.
  3. Huge list of applications in repos, though I would use only a couple which are readily availble in alomst all distros. Package management is a breeze through Synaptic.
  4. Skype download page has a version for Ubuntu and it works perfectly with Mint.
  5. All media formats work out of Box. Youtube, flash, mp3 you name it and it works in Mint.
  6. System config is centralized. Now this is one of the best feature in Mandriva, I was relieved to finid similar one in Mint. Though I must say Mandriav is much more exhaustive and refined.
  7. Hibernation works with little tweaking, though I must say VISTA still outclasses it by leaps and bounds.
  8. Stablity. No crashes even in LIVE CD mode. Installed version looks more promissing.
  9. Speed. I can bet tha Mandriva is anyday faster. Right from bootup to application open time, Mandriva is much faster. However, Mint is not very slow as compared. Though I can feel the slowness, it is not a Black Mark. I will not use this on my main system, which is accustomed to speeds offered by Arch Linux.
  10. Look and Feel. The more you say the less it is. In its default form it just impressed us too much. Compiz bring more eye candy. The transparent Titlebar, translucent windows when dragging, the inactive windows all make you feel wow. I think the implementation is as good as Win 7.

Conclusion :

Mint is not just one of the best looking distribution I have come across, its also one of the most easier to use. 90% of things work out of box and for the remaining there is Mint and Ubuntu Forums ;). Its an eye candy, which is eaqually easy to administer and at the same time very stable. Long time KDE users like me would be at ease with Mint's GNOME implementation.

Its a distribution which I can easily give to my Windows friends to try and be assured that they will atleast use it often as a LIVE CD if not install it on hard disk. The menu and options are evry intutive to a Windows Guy and would make the transition easy. The GUI is as good looking as Win 7 and would appeal to all.

Unfortunately, this is not a perfect world. Even Mint has some issues. If the devs can improve the speed and make hibernation less painfull, Mint has all the possibilities to become the default option for Home users.

39 comments:

Unknown said...

Why not try the KDE version of Mint? I'm with you, I much prefer KDE.

Sylvainsjc said...

Hi,
I spent several years with Fedora / Ubuntu / Linux Mint/ Kubuntu to finally find Mandriva (I use 2010.0 Kde 32)

I prefer KDE to Gnome and my last try was Linux Mint Helena Kde 32 CE

About Mint, let me say :

- The boot screen (grub + usplash) is horrible if you compare to Mandriva grub / plymouth boot and speed

Ubuntu / Mint Grub managment is ugly and you are forced to use the terminal if you want to add another OS

Software managment : to find a software, firstly you try with mint software manager and if you don't find, then you try with synaptic

- No equivalent to the great Mandriva Control Centre to manage nearly all without using the terminal

Mandriva is also known to recognize a lot of hardware and and loads a lot of proprietary drivers

Klopus said...

I'm avoiding Mint simply because of Mint's top guy badly mixes politics and open source. Few months back he passionately demanded anyone from a certain country not to download or use Mint. To me it's so contrary to the nature of open source, so offensive and generalizing that since then I avoid Mint like a plague and tell everybody to do same.

Abhay said...

Thanks for the comments.

I wanted to try the official evrsion of Mint and sepnd some tiem with it. Now that I have done it, I'll try the KDE version.

I totally agree that Mint is slower than Mandriva. I have noticed it couple of times.
Also Mandriva Control centre is great tool. Actually I have mentioned these two points in my original post. However Mint is stabler than Mandriva; atleast on my Vaio. My wife would not mind slowness ( She is used to of VISTA) but stability is a big thing. If the UI Freezes, she will immediately boot back to VISTA.

Unknown said...

Fashion is all about lookingmoncler jackets good and being comfortable at the same time. monclermoncler coatsEvery woman loves being complimentedmoncler t-shirtmoncler vestmoncler outlet for her sense of style and elegance. ugg bootscheap ugg bootsdiscount ugg bootsNo woman wants to be labeled as outdated and old

fashioned.ugg classic tall bootsclassic ugg bootsWomen are expected to be in constant touch with the latest trends in ordermoncler

jackets
monclernew moncler coats to adopt those trends and look fashionable

and stylish. moncler vestmoncler outletmoncler

polo t-shirt
Women need to make sure that whatever they wear, coach outletcoach handbagscoach bagsit should compliment their personality and they do

not feel awkward while wearing it. coach totescoach

outlet
louis vuitton handbagsAn article about Gothic costume clothing and the importance of choosing Gothic choker.

LV handbags 2010Louis Vuitton bagsLouis Vuitton totesThis article explores the wide variety of Gothicrain boots
rainweardiesel jeans chokers available from everyday to special

occasions. Ture Religion Jeanslevis jeansabercrombie and fitch outletIt should inspire people to go shopping for their own Gothic chokers. ed hardy wholesaleed hardy outletcheap ed hardy

wholesale
The origins of the Flat cap span discount ed hardy wholesalewholesale ed hardy

King Bayern Munich said...

Hello, very professional high level of writing it! So many people to comment, let me also to comment on it. Because good writing, and I learned a lot, and I am glad to see such a beautiful thing. Thanks very much !the same time, i love Safety Valve
Oh, so unexpected, so surprise! Very touching, so well written and I have some perception, learning very much. Thank you for sharing. Very happy to see these and believe that your point of view. This same time,i love pressure relief valve

Nike shox clearance said...

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.

led said...

Christian Louboutin Tall Boots
Christian Louboutin Wedges
Christian Louboutin Pumps
Christian Louboutin Sandals
Jimmy Choo Shoes
Moncler Kid's Jackets
Moncler clothing wholesale
Wholesale Moncler Jackets
discount Moncler Jackets
http://www.shopmoncler.hk/moncler-jackets
http://www.utsource.net/BUK444-500B.html
http://www.utsource.net/MG50Q6ES41.html
http://www.utsource.net/UM150CDY-10.html
http://www.utsource.net/MP7002.html
http://www.utsource.net/TMS320F2812PGFA.html
http://www.utsource.net/CEM3374.html
http://www.utsource.net/2sj74.html

discount asics shoes said...

You write really good articles, very attractive, I feel very shocked. I hope you can continue with your work, come on!

Tiffany Jewelry said...

so many useful information for us. thank you. wish you a happy 2o11.

Unknown said...

联系方式
黄坤 15:56:17
鸿运园店 地址:沙县西园鸿运园13幢A-85号(莲花十字路口往小吃城方向300米)
黄坤 15:56:36
莲花店 地址:沙县西山市场斜对面自来水公司旁
黄坤 15:56:56
联系方式 联系电话:15080590110 联系人:罗小姐 客服QQ:1539866553

skin tag removal said...

Great story as for me. It would be great to read a bit more concerning this matter. Thank you for posting that data.

stretch mark removal cream said...

It was a very convincing letter that may change the mind of a certain user. But then, the DKE maybe more slower upon pressing the function of the GNU in a particular desk.

skin tag removal said...

This was an awesome blog post! I enjoyed reading this wonderful blog post. Thank you for sharing this. I will be back in this site later to check of any updates.

Buy Soma said...

Hey i want to migrate from Ubuntu to Mint, what you can recommend to read me?

how to burn xbox 360 games said...

Indeed really interesting article and I also wanted to discuss a little bit but a tons of spam comments won't to do this.

Buy Generic Propecia Online said...

Thanks for the review. I think it would be a great thing for the USA too.

pradashoeslove said...

Thank you for sharing it with us. It is useful for me.

Ray Ban Sunglasses said...

Thanks for sharing. We might feel worthless to one person, but we are priceless to another. Don't ever forget your value.

Prada shoes said...

Thanks for sharing. The best way to escape from the past is not to avoid or forget it, but to accept and forgive it.

Nike mercurial soccer cleats said...

Ah good exciting content! Will always come to our attention. To bring you good news-works perfect! New nike soccer shoes best shoes 2011!!nike vapor soccer shoes.

stop sweating naturally said...

I do hope my post here won't be deleted. There are quite many spammers here but I am not one of them. I am just curious how they behave.

how to treat hemorrhoids said...

Excellent write-up tends to make continual development, many thanks discuss, the particular deposition regarding information is always to retain studying, consideration will be the beginning of success.

Anonymous said...

What to buy Christmas gifts for friends: The lasting for Mercurial Vapor Superfly Football is on the way to be to hold on to innovate. As Nike’s CEO Mark Parker mentioned “The obsession for innovations is frequently duty amount one for Nike Mercurial Superfly.” Nike Football exists to create Mercurial Vapors football boots and products near to the player, in accordance with his man or ladies demands – speed, power, accuracy, to name only a few.

美麗資訊攻略站 said...

25
Live Keywords:蛋糕 彌月蛋糕 棧板 隔熱紙 關鍵字 蛋糕 回頭車 江詩丹頓 高仿手錶 棧板 棧板 防水工程 瑜珈教室 隆乳

26
Hot Keywords:除蟲公司 捕蚊達人 民宿 隆乳 整形外科 關鍵字排名 泌尿科 隆鼻 電波拉皮 眼袋 裝潢 室內設計作品 人工植牙 拉皮

27
Live Keywords:香港民宿 平價住宿 防治白蟻 白蟻 天麻 關鍵字排名 扭力板手 歐米茄 貨運公司 熱水器 塑膠棧板 人工植牙 廚具 抽脂

28
Hot Keywords:塑膠棧板 塑膠棧板 抓漏工程 跳蚤 宜蘭民宿 網頁設計 香港旅館 大陸新娘 大陸新娘 大陸新娘 植髮 瑜珈 設計 雙眼皮

alcohol and viagra said...

Wow, nice post,there are many person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post

ipad blackjack said...

I think you have to try the KDE version of mint.

Jude Gates said...

Your web site is really educational. Merely telling you that I added your website to several my favorite bookmarking internet sites; I really hope that it can get you much more well deserved targeted traffic.buy tramadol cod

Greg said...

Thank !I really love to read this post

China tours said...

What a beautiful dragonfly and what wonderful post!!I am a china tour lover,You can learn more: China tour operator | China tour packages | China city travel

facebook iniciar sesion celular said...

This is wonderful. This is precisely the article I needed to read today
---
facebook iniciar sesion celular |facebook iniciar sesion | facebook iniciar sesion celular gratis

mobogenie baixar said...

Thanks for all your information, Website is very nice and informative content.
---
i like play game click jogos online free and apply baixar facebook movel online free and apply mobogenie online free

Unknown said...

Its really good information, i like your blog post. Thanks for sharing
i like play games friv online and play games2girls 2 online free and play game friv games and games 2 girls ! have fun!

facebook iniciar sesion celular said...

I like it very much,very good post.
----
facebook movil gratis and facebook movil and apply facebook iniciar sesion celular gratis

Unknown said...

Thank you for that information you article
Signature:
facebook entrar iniciar sesion gratis - Sitio Oficial iniciado sesión en Facebook lengua española. facebook entrar rápido, facebook iniciar sesion en tu cuenta de entrar facebook

agar io said...

Thank you for sharing valuable information. Nice post. I enjoyed reading this post.
descargar facebook , facebook movel baixar , baixar whatsapp , whatsapp baixar , mobogenie , facebook movel

güzel sözler said...

thnak you

Harry135 said...

Great Post!
Thanks for sharing this informative post...
If You have unplanned pregnancy problem then you can Buy Abortion Pills Online with fast delivery.

buy tapentadol 100mg online said...

Tapentadol is a medication used to treat moderate to severe pain, such as that caused by injury, surgery, or chronic conditions like arthritis or neuropathy.

Google
 
Techzone